• Skip to content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Decision Desk HQ

Elections Returns, Analysis and Projections

  • Home
  • Results
  • Forecasting
  • Services

Former SC Governor Nikki Haley First to Challenge Trump for 2024 GOP Nomination

February 16, 2023 by Zachary Donnini

Former South Carolina Governor Nikki Haley officially launched her campaign for President of the United States on Wednesday morning with an event in her home city of Charleston, South Carolina. Haley is the first major candidate to announce she will compete against former President Donald Trump for the Republican nomination in 2024. Haley was raised as a Sikh by her Indian immigrant parents, but converted to Christianity after marrying her husband, Michael Haley, in 1997. She served in the South Carolina House of Representatives for six years and as Governor of South Carolina for six more before being appointed as the Ambassador of the U.S. to the United Nations by former President Donald Trump. Haley would be both the first woman and the first American of Asian descent to be elected President.

Although Trump and Florida Governor Ron DeSantis receive the majority of national attention and are the clear favorites to win the 2024 nomination, prediction markets suggest Haley is clearly the third most likely candidate to advance to the general election. Haley’s decision to run for President contrasts her previous position when she argued she would not challenge Trump for the Republican nomination if he chose to seek it himself. Although Haley and Trump held a working relationship during the first portion of his term, their relationship has soured since the 2020 election. Haley endorsed Trump over Hillary Clinton and Joe Biden in 2016 and 2020 but has recently been more critical of his actions as President in the aftermath of the 2020 presidential election, noting that she was “angry” and his actions “will be judged harshly by history.”

 

Nikki Haley Scouting Report

Check out our recent article breaking down GOP Primary voters into five groups of voters in detail.

 

Strengths

Social Moderates

Social Moderates prioritize a combination of electability and fiscal conservatism over anything else, and Haley delivers on both counts. Given that these voters often tend to be younger and low-info, her positive identity politics (a woman of color) will also help her gain support with this group. However, although she has begun to criticize former President Trump since the January 6th Capitol attack, Haley still lacks the credentials to win over true “Never Trump” protest voters over a candidate like Larry Hogan.

Reagan Republicans

Although Reagan Republicans are more conservative on most issues than Social Moderates, together they form the traditional GOP establishment. They should initially be considered Haley’s strongest base of support. While happy to support Trump over Biden, they tend to disagree with Trump’s assertions of election fraud in the 2020 presidential election and may want to move past Trump and Trumpism in 2024. These voters are searching for a strong, steady, and electable conservative to support against Trump, and should Ron DeSantis decide not to run, could propel Haley into his sphere of national stardom.

 

Weaknesses

Only Trump 

Haley will likely be one of the most solid challengers among Only Trump voters. Trump has begun to publically attack her, but not quite to the extent of other potential challengers such as DeSantis and former Maryland Governor Larry Hogan (though, this could change once the campaign heats up). Although Trump seems likely to go down fighting rather than dropping out and endorsing other candidates, low-information Trump supporters could at least connect her positively with the former President.

Populist Right

Nikki Haley is an establishmentarian, not a populist. She is likely to tout her experience as US ambassador to the United Nations as necessary experience to be President. To the extent she attempts to court these voters, her challenge will be presenting that experience in a way that does not conflict with their isolationist and anti-establishment views. For example, Haley has consistently spoken out in favor of funding Ukraine and disappointed right-wingers when she removed the Confederate Flag from the South Carolina State Capitol during her time as governor.

The Evangelical Right

Given that neither Trump nor DeSantis have an uncommonly close relationship with The Evangelical Right, these voters may serve as the key battleground for prospective 2024 Republican candidates. Mike Pence helped Trump cement the support of these voters in 2016, but their relationship has turned notably south since. This at least opens a window of opportunity for Haley given her conservative social views and genuine embrace of “family values,” though she is unlikely to become the preferred Christian conservative candidate in the primary.

 

Haley’s First Four Advantage

Given that Haley’s home state of South Carolina will likely be a “First Four” primary, she will have a chance to gain momentum early in the campaign with a strong result. That being said, it will effectively end Haley’s campaign if she is unable to score a victory on her home turf.

 

Summary

Behind Donald Trump and Ron DeSantis, Nikki Haley may have the widest appeal and brightest prospects out of any other 2024 GOP Presidential candidate. She is conservative enough to win the support of the most conservative voters, but will not alienate moderates with her rhetoric. Her establishmentarian rhetoric and views will cause GOP primary voters to view her as an electable candidate come November of 2024 and will play especially well in the suburbs and exurbs.

Haley will have to overcome plenty of obstacles in order to win the nomination. Her name recognition and public profile lag far behind DeSantis and she will start at a massive fundraising disadvantage. Establishment Republican voters will be keen to prevent a second coming of 2016 when a variety of GOP challengers split opposition against Trump, allowing him to claim the nomination without ever facing a real challenge.

Filed Under: 2024 Elections, 2024 President, Analysis Tagged With: 2024 GOP Presidential Primary, 2024 Presidential Election, 2024 Presidential Primary, Donald Trump, Nikki Haley, Ron DeSantis, South Carolina

Primary Sidebar

Sign Up for a Free DDHQ Results Account and Newsletter Subscription

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Projects

  • 2020 Election Forecasting
  • 2020/2021 Election Results Dashboard
  • 2018 Midterm Forecasting
  • 2018 Midterm Simulator

Search By Category

2020 President 2022 Midterms 2023 Elections 2024 Elections 2024 President Ad Spending Analysis Covid-19 Delegate Count Forecasting Model Governor Guest Editorial House International Elections Mapping Methodology municipal elections News Podcast Polling Predictions Race Preview Race Update Ranked-Choice Voting Results Senate Special Election - Congressional Special Election- State Legislature UK 2019 Election Uncategorized Virgina Legislative Results

Search By Month

Footer

  • Services
  • About
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

© 2021 Decision Desk HQ ALL RIGHTS RESERVED

This site uses cookies and external scripts to improve your experience.

Privacy settings

Privacy Settings

This site uses cookies and external scripts to improve your experience. Which cookies and scripts are used and how they impact your visit is specified on the left. You may change your settings at any time. Your choices will not impact your visit.

NOTE: These settings will only apply to the browser and device you are currently using.

Google Analytics

Powered by Cookie Information